Evaluation Using Scenarios
Scenario-based assessment evaluates an architecture by examining scenarios relevant to the system.
Scenarios help assess whether architectural decisions support the required quality attributes.
Scenario-Based Assessment Approaches
| Approach | Full Name |
|---|---|
| ATAM | Architecture Trade-off Analysis Method |
| CBAM | Cost Benefits Analysis Method |
| SAAM | Software Architecture Analysis Method |
| SBAR | Scenario Based Architecture Re-Engineering |
Architecture Trade-Off Analysis Method (ATAM)
ATAM is an architecture evaluation method used to analyze architectural decisions and their effects on quality attributes.
It helps identify:
- Trade-offs
- Sensitivity points
- Non-risks
- Risks
- Risk themes
ATAM Process
The ATAM process illustrated connects business requirements, quality attributes, scenarios, architectural decisions, and analysis.
Step 1: Identify Business Drivers
Business drivers provide the business context and goals that influence the architecture.
They help establish what the system needs to achieve.
Step 2: Identify Quality Attributes
Identify the quality attributes that matter to the system.
These attributes provide criteria for examining the architecture.
Step 3: Develop Scenarios
Scenarios describe situations that help evaluate whether the architecture satisfies the required quality attributes.
Step 4: Examine the Software Architecture
The process considers the software architecture and the architectural approaches used to realize it.
Step 5: Identify Architectural Decisions
Identify the architectural decisions that influence the system’s quality attributes.
Step 6: Analyze the Architecture
Analyze the relationship between:
- Business drivers
- Quality attributes
- Scenarios
- Architectural approaches
- Architectural decisions
The analysis identifies the consequences of architectural decisions.
Step 7: Identify Analysis Results
The ATAM process identifies several important results.
| Result | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Trade-offs | Decisions that affect multiple quality attributes, potentially improving one while negatively affecting another. |
| Sensitivity Points | Architectural decisions or properties that strongly affect a quality attribute. |
| Non-risks | Architectural decisions that have been identified as not posing a risk in the evaluated context. |
| Risks | Architectural decisions or conditions that may prevent the system from achieving its required qualities. |
| Risk Themes | Groups or patterns of related risks identified during analysis. |
Understanding ATAM Results
Trade-Offs
A trade-off occurs when an architectural decision affects multiple quality attributes in different ways.
For example, improving one quality attribute may negatively affect another.
Sensitivity Points
A sensitivity point is an architectural decision or property that has a significant effect on a quality attribute.
Changes to sensitivity points can have important consequences for the system.
Risks and Risk Themes
A risk is an architectural concern that may prevent the system from achieving its quality requirements.
Risk themes summarize related risks to help stakeholders understand broader architectural concerns.
Importance of ATAM
ATAM helps stakeholders understand how architectural decisions affect quality attributes.
It provides a structured approach to identifying trade-offs, sensitivity points, and risks before they become costly problems.